The Commissioner's Cup is a rotating trophy awarded to the institution that garners the most overall all-sports' points during the year.

Current All-Sports Standings

 2012-13 Commissioner's Cup Standings 

Place	School	Men's	Women's	Total
1.	Franklin	66.0	60.7	126.7
2.	Rose-Hulman	66.5	54.5	121.0
3.	Hanover	53.0	61.0	114.0
4.	Transylvania	50.0	59.0	109.0
5.	Manchester	50.7	54.7	105.4
6.	Defiance	47.5	42.2	89.7
7.	Anderson	39.8	35.5	75.3
8.	Mount St. Joseph	34.7	25.5	60.2
9.	Bluffton	25.8	30.0	55.8
10.	Earlham	25.0	25.0	50.0

 

Past HCAC Commissioner's Cup Winners  

Year	School	Points
11-12	Transylvania	112.0
10-11	Transylvania	107.66
09-10	Rose-Hulman	96.0
08-09	Franklin	95.5
07-08	Rose-Hulman	103.0
06-07	Anderson	92.5
05-06	Manchester	81.0