Note: Games in Dark Blue Indicate Conference Contests; Bold Indicates Victor
| Date | Away | Score | Home | Score | |||
| Aug. 31 | Mount St. Joseph | 2nd | Mount St. Joseph Invitational | out of 4 | Final | Results | |
| Transylvania | Mount St. Joseph Invitational | No Team Score | Final | Results | |||
| Sep. 1 | Anderson | 7th | Wabash Hokem Karem | out of 7 | Final | Results | |
| Bluffton | 4th | Ohio Northern Invitational | out of 4 | Final | Results | ||
| Defiance | 3rd | Manchester Hokum Karem | out of 3 | Final | Results | ||
| Earlham | 6th | Franklin Invitational | out of 6 | Final | Results | ||
| Hanover | 5th | Franklin Invitational | out of 6 | Final | Results | ||
| Manchester | 2nd | Manchester Hokum Karem | out of 3 | Final | Results | ||
| Franklin | 4th | Franklin Invitational | out of 6 | Final | Results | ||
| Sep. 8 | Bluffton | 3rd | Bluffton Invitational | out of 3 | Final | Results | |
| Defiance | 2nd | Bluffton Invitational | out of 3 | Final | Results | ||
| Hanover | 2nd | Hanover Invitational | out of 4 | Final | Results | ||
| Mount St. Joseph | 3rd | Hanover Invitational | out of 4 | Final | Results | ||
| Transylvania | 4th | Hanover Invitational | out of 4 | Final | Results | ||
| Franklin | 1st | Hanover Invitational | out of 4 | Final | Results | ||
| Manchester | 1st | Bluffton Invitational | out of 3 | Final | Results | ||
| Sep. 14 | Anderson | 12th | Indiana Intercollegiates | out of 19 | Final | Results | |
| Terre Haute, IN | |||||||
| Earlham | 17th | Indiana Intercollegiates | out of 19 | Final | Results | ||
| Terre Haute, IN | |||||||
| Hanover | 13th | Indiana Intercollegiates | out of 19 | Final | Results | ||
| Terre Haute, IN | |||||||
| Manchester | 4th | Indiana Intercollegiates | out of 19 | Final | Results | ||
| Terre Haute, IN | |||||||
| Rose-Hulman | 10th | Indiana Intercollegiates | out of 19 | Final | Results | ||
| Terre Haute, IN | |||||||
| Franklin | 9th | Indiana Intercollegiates | out of 19 | Final | Results | ||
| Terre Haute, IN | |||||||
| Sep. 15 | Defiance | 3rd | Penn State-Behrend Invitational | out of 17 | Final | Results | |
| Sep. 22 | Bluffton | 5th | Otterbein Invitational | out of 9 | Final | Results | |
| Sep. 29 | Anderson | 3rd | Earlham Invitational | out of 4 | Final | Results | |
| Bluffton | 39th | All-Ohio Championships | out of 44 | Final | Results | ||
| Cedarville, OH | |||||||
| Defiance | 33rd | All-Ohio Championships | out of 44 | Final | Results | ||
| Cedarville, OH | |||||||
| Earlham | 4th | Earlham Invitational | out of 4 | Final | Results | ||
| Hanover | 24th | Louisville Classic | out of 38 | Final | Results | ||
| Mount St. Joseph | 44th | All-Ohio Championships | out of 44 | Final | Results | ||
| Cedarville, OH | |||||||
| Rose-Hulman | 1st | Earlham Invitational | out of 4 | Final | Results | ||
| Transylvania | Earlham Invitational | No Team Score | Final | Results | |||
| Franklin | 9th | Louisville Classic | out of 38 | Final | Results | ||
| Oct. 6 | Hanover | 28th | NCAA Pre-Nationals | out of 30 | Final | Results | |
| Terre Haute, IN | |||||||
| Manchester | 8th | NCAA Pre-Nationals | out of 30 | Final | Results | ||
| Terre Haute, IN | |||||||
| Mount St. Joseph | 30th | NCAA Pre-Nationals | out of 30 | Final | Results | ||
| Terre Haute, IN | |||||||
| Rose-Hulman | 22nd | NCAA Pre-Nationals | out of 30 | Final | Results | ||
| Terre Haute, IN | |||||||
| Franklin | 23rd | NCAA Pre-Nationals | out of 30 | Final | Results | ||
| Terre Haute, IN | |||||||
| Oct. 12 | Anderson | 19th | Wilmington Invitational | out of 34 | Final | Results | |
| Defiance | 15th | Wilmington Invitational | out of 34 | Final | Results | ||
| Earlham | 28th | Wilmington Invitational | out of 34 | Final | Results | ||
| Hanover | 16th | Wilmington Invitational | out of 34 | Final | Results | ||
| Mount St. Joseph | 31st | Wilmington Invitational | out of 34 | Final | Results | ||
| Rose-Hulman | 7th | Wilmington Invitational | out of 34 | Final | Results | ||
| Transylvania | 33rd | Wilmington Invitational | out of 34 | Final | Results | ||
| Franklin | 10th | Wilmington Invitational | out of 34 | Final | Results | ||
| Oct. 13 | Bluffton | 24th | Oberlin Invitational | out of 32 | Final | Results | |
| Manchester | 1st | Manchester Invitational | out of 5 | Final | Results | ||
| Oct. 27 | HCAC Championships | Final | Box Score | Results | ||||
| Bluffton, OH | |||||||
| Nov. 10 | NCAA Division III Great Lakes Regional | Final | Results | ||||
| Anderson, IN | |||||||
| Nov. 17 | Manchester | 29th | NCAA Division III Championship | out of 32 | Final | Results | |
| Terre Haute, IN | |||||||
